Metal vs. Asphalt Shingle: Which Roof is Better?
The most important decision when installing a new roof is selecting the material. Asphalt and metal roofs are two of the most popular options. Both are excellent choices, but one may better suit your needs.
Let’s dive into the crucial features of asphalt and metal roofs to determine the better material.
Metal offers greater durability
Metal roofing can withstand extreme weather conditions. The warranties cover damage for up to 30 or 50 years. However, these roofs often exceed this range with a lifespan of 70 years. That said, they’re not impervious. Falling branches and extreme hail can dent their surface, and improper installation can make them even more vulnerable.
Asphalt shingles have a shorter lifespan. Damp conditions can result in fungus and algae growth, whereas ice dams often cause cracks. In addition, temperature fluctuations also have an adverse effect. As a result, they come with 15-year and 30-year warranties.
Asphalt is more affordable upfront
Although metal roofing is a wiser long-term investment, it has a much higher installation price. They generally go for $120 to $900 per 100 square feet, whereas asphalt usually doesn’t cost more than $200 per 100 square feet. The installation is pricier with metal, as the job is more complex.
On the flip side, homeowners with metal roofs can recoup the costs down the line since they may not need to replace them. Moreover, insurance companies frequently offer discounts to households with metal roofing.
Metal roofing is environmentally friendly
Since it mainly consists of recycled materials, metal roofing is more sustainable than asphalt. It also boasts greater energy efficiency due to reflective qualities, blocking heat from getting inside the house. Specialized coatings can lower cooling bills even further.
In contrast, asphalt shingles aren’t sustainable and require frequent replacement, resulting in tons of waste in landfills. Furthermore, they are petroleum-based products, increasing the household’s reliance on fossil fuels.
Asphalt shingles are easier to mount and repair
Professional roofers typically breeze through the installation of asphalt shingles. The process doesn’t require vast knowledge or cutting-edge tools. Sometimes, they can be installed in as little as 24 hours, and roofers often place them over an existing layer.
On the other hand, mounting a metal roof warrants specialized craftsmanship. The job is far more precise, and there’s little room for error. Consequently, it doesn’t move as fast as the asphalt shingle installation.
Still, some lightweight solutions may be placed atop an existing roof, provided it’s in good shape. In this case, it simplifies the installation and eliminates the costs of removing the original roofing.
Metal roof or asphalt shingle roof?
Overall, metal roofs provide more robust properties than asphalt. They’re more durable and energy-efficient, saving money down the line. But if you’re looking for rapid installation and minimal upfront costs, asphalt is the better choice.
For more help finding the best roof material for your house, consult a dependable roofing company.
Master Pro Services provides expert roofing repair and replacement in Richmond, Chesterfield, Midlothian, Hopewell, Ashland, Glen Allen, Moseley, Fort Lee, and surrounding areas. Our services encompass all residential and commercial roofing structures, including flat roofs, Dimensional, three-tab, designer shingles, metal roofing, EPDM roof membranes, thermoplastic roof membranes (TPO), as well as windows, gutters, and other roofing components. Financing is available. BBB member. Call us now at (804) 552-5007.
